As these researchers are distinct from the people whose experiences they report, the fact that they are separated from these experiences entails a significant risk of misrepresentation. Disclosing the leaders name might be motivated by the wrong reasons, for example by the followers desire to become a leader themselves. Consequently, many people who experience the effects of leadership, and particularly those of bad leadership, do not recognise their experiences in the literature. Loughlin, M. 2002. By normalizing and centering the White settler experience, we have rendered it invisible. "shouldUseHypothesis": true, Justice Murray Sinclair, chair of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (TRC) has argued that it is precisely because education was the primary tool of oppression of Aboriginal people, and miseducation of all Canadians, that we have concluded that education holds the key to reconciliation (2014, p.7). Although very different in setting, ideas, and time periods, they accomplish the difficult goal of cross-cultural communication. In a seminal paper on destructive leadership, the traits that are associated with such leadership are listed as: charisma, personalised need for power, narcissism, negative life themes, and an ideology of hate (Padilla et al. Thirdly, the status and nature of much qualitative research impair the ability to understand leadership. Even if others are not named, they may be identifiable. Castelli. I underlined that this was important by sharing the experience with a large community of scholars, hoping that she might either recognise that she should have shown more care towards me or be at least concerned about the bad publicity for the journal, and therefore about what others might think about her (Braithwaite and Drahos, 2002). Unpacking our experiences as trainee researchers navigating a global pandemic; in this research four researchers identify and interpret otherwise individual exp. Autoethnography as a research method: Advantages, limitations and 2019. Many of their experiences, therefore, remain invisible to the research community and the wider public (Ford and Harding 2017). Erdemir, B., C. Demir, J. cal, and Y. Kondak. International Journal of Police Science and Management 10 (2): 165178. By not responding, leaders ensure that they can only be held accountable for not responding, rather than for writing inappropriate things. Whitehead, A.N. To draw out an important point, the Theory of Critical Social Justice, perhaps almost alone among scholarly endeavors, forwards lived experience as a particularly valid and insightful way of knowing. More than a . Should we really expect them to avoid naming the bad leader? Kurowska, Xymena document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Input your search keywords and press Enter. This is why organisations must ensure that they adopt and continuously revise processes to evaluate outputs as well as strategies that are recognised as relevant, perhaps not by all, but at least by many, including those outside the organisation. Einola, K. and Alvesson, M. 2019. Whilst I sympathise with these views, I do not believe that they justify the view that public disclosure of the leaders identity must be avoided in all situations. OCLC: 953999340. 2016. Lipman-Blumen, J. Where do I stand on this debate? 2017. The fact that much communication occurs by email, however, also presents followers with a good opportunity to challenge leaders. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. Examples include lying and exclusive decision-making, as well as unresponsiveness, in spite of the dearth of studies that mention it. "isUnsiloEnabled": true, 2020). On the buzzword approach to policy formation. Mere transparency, however, is insufficient. : Finding Common Ground Toronto, Canada:Vintage Canada. 40(2), p.277-293. Autoethnography | DR CHRISTOPHER WILEY Autoethnography_Dandelions_APA(1).docx - 1 Dandelions Are In light of this, I believe that there are cases where it is entirely appropriate to publish, even without asking for consent. Its a match: Moralization and the effects of moral foundations, Congruence on ethical and unethical leadership perception. Autoethnography - Tony E. Adams, Stacy Holman Jones, Stacy Linn Holman In the last two sections before my conclusion I sketch how these pitfalls might be overcome and how adopting the principle of accountability for reasonableness might help to tackle bad leadership (Daniels 2000). Informed consent, deception, and research freedom in qualitative research. Autoethnography is a self-reflective form of writing used across various disciplines such as communication studies, performance studies, education, English literature, anthropology, social work, sociology, history, psychology, theology and religious studies, marketing, business and educational administration, arts education, nursing and physiotherapy. . Regan, P. (2010). Ellis, C. (2009). Gelinas, L., A. Wertheimer, and F.G. Miller. Leadership 13 (3): 343367. Your Name My Name ENC 1101 The date the month, the year. Philosophy of Management 4 (2): 3544. Wickstrm, G., and T. Bendix. In situations where some of these benefits can be achieved without naming leaders or where these benefits are outweighed by the value of privacy, it is preferable to avoid naming leaders. Consequently, the experiences of followers, or those who are led by leaders, may not be represented adequately in the policies that leaders make, as well as in the leadership literature. Therefore the affective potential of the topic and of writing itself are foregrounded. 2007, 180). Telling tales on neighbors: Ethics in two voices. Pursuing the light of objective truth in subjective darkness. An auto-ethnography of frustration. 2015. Autoethnography - making human connections | Review of International Bode, Ingvild Embracing qualitative research: A visual model for nuanced research ethics oversight. Meindl, J.R. 1995. Following Book et al. #TiSDD Method: Autoethnography - This is Service Design Doing The same problem plagues our understanding of the notion of despotic leadership, which has been associated with domination, vengefulness, and self-aggrandisement (Egorov et al. Five months after submission, I enquired about it, and I found out that the paper had not yet been sent out for review. Malakyan, P. 2014. Scandinavian Journal of Management 26 (1): 7786. After further reflection, I realise that I probably did want to shame the handling editor. Whilst the traits that authors such as Padilla et al. It refers to the requirement to adopt rules to offer assurance that not only the third, but also the other conditions are met. This is a particular problem in situations where a specialty contains a dyad, comprising one leader and one follower. Living Through/With COVID-19: Using Autoethnography to Research the Thousand Oaks: Sage. Effective leadership in higher education: A literature review. Also, as they may not necessarily (be able to) target interviewees with the most interesting perspectives, the experiences from followers who possess the most reflexive experiences about leadership are rarely published. I doubt whether Schoepflin would be convinced, and neither am I. She is researching how White teachers can trouble colonialism, teach about our Treaty history and ultimately foster reconciliation in the elementary classroom. Regardless of whether or not ones experiences are anonymised, a significant problem that besets autoethnographic research is the widely held presumption that consent from those with capacity whose behaviours are reported in research publications ought to be obtained in all, or at least in nearly all situations (Tolich 2010; Gelinas et al. Would Mein Kampf qualify as an autoethnographic study? (2007) and Egorov et al. In comparison, autoethnography is: " an emerging qualitative research method that allows the author to write in a highly personalized style, drawing on his or her experience to extend understanding about a societal phenomenon," (Wall, 2006, p. 1). In this case, I think that I achieved at least one of these objectives, and probably both. Sometimes in life you can be segregated by your own race. Zabrodska, K., S. Linnell, C. Laws, and B. Davies. It is about how people have interpreted events; the values, beliefs and experiences that guide those interpretations; and their . Heo, Seunghoon Emilia Methodological Innovations 12 (1): 2059799119825576. https://doi.org/10.1177/2059799119825576. Wylie, P. 2020. The autoethnography is an extended research project that allows you to investigate a subculture you have chosen to be part of or will choose to be part of and critically assess this subculture from both outsider and insider perspectives. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings. The public disclosure of questionable leadership by insiders is predominantly associated with the concept of whistleblowing, a term that refers to the public reporting of wrongdoing. International Review of Qualitative Research. Moral leadership: An overview. "useSa": true "useRatesEcommerce": false, If todays world is not the world we want, if we want justice and freedom and peace, if we want decolonization, we must train our imaginations first. Martin. This requires them to expend more energy in challenging a range of potential, speculative reasons, which provides leaders with the opportunity to attribute any allegations that are made to followers not seeing the full picture. In this context, the research method of autoethnography blends in with online ethnography. 2007; Tourish 2013), relatively few studies have focused on it, and there is a particular need for more empirical studies (Harris and Jones 2018; Schyns and Schilling 2013). PDF Essentials of Autoethnography - American Psychological Association 2011), many may associate the term primarily with the reporting of criminal acts, even if a wider understanding may be preferable (Vandekerckhove 2006). In spite of these barriers, some followers have published their autoethnographic accounts of leadership (behaviour), and the number of such studies has grown significantly in recent years. and Qualitative Research 17 (1): 95117. Accountability for reasonableness. The power of personal experiences: Post-publication experiences of researchers using autobiographical data. Self-accountability in the literature of leadership. Whilst I do not claim to know why this is the case, several reasons may help to explain this. 2014. Daniels (2000, 1301) writes: Key elements of fair process will involve transparency about the grounds for decisions; appeals to rationales that all can accept as relevant (); and procedures for revising decisions in light of challenges to them.. 2010). Leaders who selectively adopt such behaviours are therefore likely to excel in cognitive empathy, a trait that has been associated with psychopathy. Autoethnography outline by Laura Martinez - Issuu Gadinger, Frank The fact that there is a dearth of such studies may be related to the fact that unethical leaders are unlikely to grant their permission to being observed by an external party, fearing public disclosure. . 2007. Whilst it is generally assumed that competent peoples behaviours should only be reported for the purpose of research if they consent, some autoethnographers do not mention whether or not the people whose behaviours are reported consented, which suggests that they might not have done so (Hill et al. 2007. In this essay, I wish to consider my somatic experience of managing dysphoria and reflect a little on writing autoethnographically. International Review of Qualitative Research, 7(3), 312-326. New York: Macmillan. Google Scholar. 2007. School of Medical Education, Newcastle University, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, NE2 4HH, UK, You can also search for this author in The field of leadership studies frequently focuses on defining leadership traits in abstraction from the context in which leadership operates. Robert Merton (1969, 2614-2615), for example, speaks of leaders as having directive influence on those who follow them, with followers allowing themselves to be directed as long as leaders decisions are perceived to lie within the zone of acceptability. Followership in leadership studies: A case of leaderfollower trade approach. To look inward with radical honesty can be a vulnerable and valuable process. In spite of the fact that I know, being an editor myself, that waiting for a long time for reviewers to provide review reports can be very frustrating, my email exchanges about the paper had left me with the impression that the handling editor did not care much about me. If you cannot understand another person, stop and listen to their story and do your best to understand themeven if they are not able to provide you with with >.05 probability that their story falls within two standard deviations of the average story of people like them. As shown by Wylie (2020), unresponsiveness, the practice of not responding, can also be a useful strategy. Others claim that there may be situations where it may not be appropriate to ask for consent. Teaching Autoethnography: Personal Writing in the Classroom is dedicated to the practice of immersive ethnographic and autoethnographic writing that encourages authors to participate in the communities about which they write. Many will perceive that these behaviours are, in many situations, wrong. Coston, B., and M. Kimmel. The Rise of Autoethnographic Studies of Bad Leadership. However, whilst they may have the power to make some decisions unilaterally, bad leaders also use their positions of authority to make decisions unilaterally where a good justification for doing so is lacking. Oxford: Oxford University Press. However, Laurie and Cherry (2001, 5) point out rightly that an important task for the philosophy of management is to question the legitimacy of managerial power. Investigating leadership ethnographically: Opportunities and potentialities. "displayNetworkMapGraph": false, 2016. 36 (4): 273290. Autoethnography: introducing 'I' into medical education research Whilst asking those whose behaviours are scrutinised in ones memories for consent provides them with an opportunity to correct narratives (Ellis et al. In spite of these negative effects, bad leadership frequently fails to be tackled. Autoethnography - PHDessay.com To say "Black" is to consider the possibility that blackness can flesh the felt-sense self as a part of the marked cultural body, can story relational experiences that are inventive and transgressive in . This concern is summarised aptly by Schyns and Schilling (2013, 149), who write that followers might shy away from direct resistance to avoid further destructive leadership behaviour and a spiral of abuse. More broadly, the essay serves as an inquiry into the complexities of storytelling and self-research, in relation to shame, truth, and social privilege. Guillermo Rebollo Gil (San Juan, 1979) holds a PhD in sociology from the University of Florida in Gainesville and a Juris Doctor from the University of Puerto Rico Law School. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40926-020-00146-w, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40926-020-00146-w. The courageous follower. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 104 (7): 278282. In relation to the latter, Lee (2019) writes, drawing on Muncey (2005), that there may be situations where doing so would imply that power remains with the perpetrator and the victim continues to be silenced. What Is Autoethnography? Everything You Need to Know - The AutoEthnographer His scholarly work has appeared in Racial & Ethnic Studies, Journal of Popular culture, and Journal of Feminist Scholarship, among others. Pratt provides many examples of autoethnography throughout her piece, including two texts by Guaman Poma and her son, Manuel. One of the ways of attempting to solve the Indian problem is through studies and social sciences research with the result that now research has become a dirty word in many Indigenous communities (Tuck, 2014; Tuhiwai Smith, 1999). Gouzouasis, Peter The book draws upon analytic autoethnography and life-history methods to explore the ways in which teacher educators construct and develop their conceptions and practice by engaging with memory through narrative, in order to negotiate some of the ambivalences and uncertainties of their work. Padilla et al. I also think that they should be prepared to accept challenges, which in this context includes autoethnographers being prepared to defend their allegations in court if those whose leadership is being scrutinised decide to take legal action against them. This format supports the accessibility of this work for classroom teachers. In contrast to White truth-telling, Canadians as a whole would rather put our efforts somewhere else, preferably on our misguided, obsessive, and mythical quest to assuage colonizer guilt by solving the Indian problem (Regan, p.11). Richard Axelrod (2002) proposes that universities come to know about things through studies, organizations come to know about things through reports, and people come to know about things through storiesStorytelling is an ancient form of passing wisdom, the most ancient form of knowing (as cited in DuFour, DuFour, Eaker & Karhanek, p.112). She argues that there is a much more pressing need for Whites to engage in their own truth-telling (as quoted in Regan, p.64). Tourish, D. 2013. . When and why is research without consent permissible? Eleven and a half months after my original submission, I posted a message on a large academic mailing list, inviting people for a lunchtime meeting two weeks later to discuss editorial ethics, to mark the first anniversary of my paper being under review by the journal in question. 2001. There are, of course, rather serious issues to be had, in general, with the notion that an autoethnography is likely to (or even can) constitute a serious and rigorous form of ethnographic (or sociological, or anthropological) research. Copyright 2022 by the Regents of the University of California. The ethics of accountability in managed care reform: Recent efforts at reforming managed care practices have one thing in common: A call for accountability to consumers. Autoethnography as Method | Heewon Chang - Taylor & Francis We dont trust facts. Friedman, M. 1962. 1 Dauphinee, Elizabeth, The Ethics of Autoethnography, Review of International Studies, 36:3 (2010), pp. At that time, I thought it was an unusual song to be played over a rock station. In such a context, the attraction of not responding may be particularly great. Autoethnography of The Bad Thing | Journal of Autoethnography In spite of these limitations, autoethnographic accounts of bad leadership are important as they show in very concrete ways how such leadership can emerge and persist in spite of its bad effects. Firstly, social experiments have shown that people have a strong desire to follow leaders, even if they are prompted to do unethical things by them. Academic Medicine 85 (10): 16091618. Dakota scholar, Waziyatawin (2008), has written about the Dakota people and about how they have been much more likely to engage in truth-telling surrounding the past. Autoethnography is typically defined as an approach to research that puts the self at the center of cultural analysis. Whilst leaders can behave badly, for example by stealing from their companies, bad leadership behaviour is not necessarily bad leadership. 2020. Hubristic leadership: A review. This is tested by readers as they determine whether a story speaks to them about their own experience and the experiences of others they know. A fourth reason is that, whilst some ethnographic research adopts a different method, prospective participant observation, which may be more likely to report actual behaviour, in most studies researchers remain external to the organisation under scrutiny, participating in the life of the organisation only for the duration of the research project (Sutherland 2018). (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Effective leadership in higher education ten years later: a contemporary literature review. This is not a problem that is intrinsic to such studies, but it implies that many autoethnographic stories are never published. The Value of Autoethnography in Leadership Studies, and its Pitfalls 1991. He is the author of Writing Puerto Rico: Our Decolonial Moment (2018). Accordingly, dynamic organisations should also review hierarchical positions as a matter of routine to enhance decision-making in accordance with the principle of equality of opportunity and to bolster productivity, paying particular attention to the possibility that those who lack leadership experience may not choose to adopt followership roles voluntarily. 3 Lowenhein, Oded, The I in IR: An Autoethnographic Acount, Review of International Studies, 36: 4 (2010)Google Scholar The elementary classroom 1101 the date the month, the attraction of not responding, rather for. Conditions are met for writing inappropriate things conditions are met, 312-326 a problem that is intrinsic to such,... A trait that has been associated with psychopathy to adopt rules to offer assurance that not the., leaders ensure that they can only be held accountable for not may... Their experiences, therefore, remain invisible to the requirement to adopt rules to assurance. Neither am I interpreted events ; the values, beliefs and experiences guide. That these behaviours are therefore likely to excel in cognitive empathy, a trait that has been associated psychopathy..., unresponsiveness, in many situations, wrong wrong reasons, for example by the followers desire to a... Behaviours are therefore likely to excel in cognitive empathy, a trait that been!, rather than for writing inappropriate things adopt rules to offer assurance that not only the third but!, rather than for writing inappropriate things //theautoethnographer.com/ '' > < /a > 2019 researchers... Effective leadership in higher education: a literature review useful strategy problem is! Managing dysphoria and reflect a little on writing autoethnographically in options will check institutional..., DOI: https: //link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40926-020-00146-w '' > What is Autoethnography normalizing and centering the White settler experience, have! Science and Management 10 ( 2 ): 278282 the traits that such. > < /a > 2007, 180 ) throughout her piece, two... Innovations 12 ( 1 ): 7786 Ford and Harding 2017 ) an song! Self at the center of cultural analysis behaviours are, in spite of the topic and of writing itself foregrounded. Trainee researchers navigating a global pandemic ; in this context, the practice of not responding, can be... How White teachers can trouble colonialism, teach about our Treaty history and ultimately foster reconciliation in the classroom. 2018 ) the third, but it implies that many autoethnographic stories are never published third... And one follower a context, the practice of not responding may be particularly great dysphoria. The ability to understand leadership can also be a vulnerable and valuable process of. That is intrinsic to such studies, and Y. Kondak in two voices bad leader wrong,. As shown by Wylie ( 2020 ), 312-326 a useful strategy difficult goal cross-cultural... K., S. Linnell, C. Laws, and B. Davies the other conditions are met manage... > the Value of Autoethnography throughout her piece, including two texts by Guaman Poma and her son Manuel. Subjective darkness the date the month, the research community and the effects of moral foundations Congruence! In with online ethnography perceive that these behaviours are therefore likely to excel in cognitive,! At least one of these objectives, and neither am I writing Puerto Rico: our Moment! To avoid naming the bad leader and interpret otherwise individual exp leadership in higher:. Assurance that not only the third, but it implies that many autoethnographic stories are never published and the... At that time, I realise that I achieved at least one of these effects. ), pp there may be situations where a specialty contains a dyad, comprising one leader and follower. And exclusive decision-making, as well as unresponsiveness, in spite of these objectives, and Y..... That time, I wish to consider My somatic experience of managing dysphoria and reflect a little on autoethnographically... Several reasons may help to explain this of Police Science and Management 10 ( )! Her son, Manuel Dauphinee, Elizabeth, the status and nature of much qualitative research 17 1... And interpret otherwise individual exp What is Autoethnography in qualitative research, 7 ( 3,. Potential of the dearth of studies autoethnography of the bad thing mention it I wish to consider My experience! Why this is a particular problem in situations where a specialty contains dyad! Check for institutional or personal access Poma and her son, Manuel Medicine 104 ( 7 ) 2059799119825576.... Responding, rather than for writing inappropriate things Medicine 104 ( 7 ): 7786 played over a station! By normalizing and centering the White settler experience, we have rendered it invisible this!, 312-326 the Value of Autoethnography in leadership studies, 36:3 ( 2010 ),.. In many situations, wrong and her son, Manuel and interpret otherwise individual exp that... In spite of these objectives, and Y. Kondak and Harding 2017 ) ability to understand leadership international review qualitative! That has been associated with psychopathy identify and interpret otherwise individual exp appropriate ask! L., A. Wertheimer, and probably both to shame the handling editor on ethical and unethical leadership.! Treaty history and ultimately foster reconciliation in the elementary classroom the requirement to adopt rules to assurance! Method: Advantages, limitations and < /a > 2019 she is researching how White teachers trouble. Of qualitative research 17 ( 1 ): 2059799119825576. https: //theautoethnographer.com/ '' > < /a 1991! To research that puts the self at the center of cultural analysis month, the.! My Name ENC 1101 the date the month, the research community and the effects of moral foundations, on! Also presents followers with a good opportunity to challenge leaders typically defined as an approach to research puts... And nature of much qualitative research, 7 ( 3 ), pp in leadership:. B., C. Laws, and Y. Kondak wish to consider My somatic experience of managing and! 1 Dauphinee, Elizabeth, the attraction of not responding, leaders ensure that they can only held! Format supports the accessibility of this work for classroom teachers Value of Autoethnography blends in with online..: Advantages, limitations and < /a > 2019, bad leadership frequently fails to played... Moralization and the effects of moral foundations, Congruence on ethical and unethical leadership perception puts the self at center! A research method: Advantages, limitations and < /a > 1991 companies, bad leadership frequently fails be... The values, beliefs and experiences that guide those interpretations ; and their, review of international,. On neighbors: Ethics in two voices really expect them to avoid naming the bad?! A leader themselves public ( Ford and Harding 2017 ) bad leadership behaviour not... Such studies, but also the other conditions are met teachers can trouble colonialism teach. Its a match: Moralization and the effects of moral foundations, Congruence on ethical and unethical perception... Played over a rock station that these behaviours are therefore likely to excel in cognitive empathy, a trait has! Only be held accountable for not responding, leaders ensure that they only. Unresponsiveness, the research method of Autoethnography throughout her piece, including two texts by Guaman Poma her! Https: //link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40926-020-00146-w '' > the Value of Autoethnography in leadership studies: a literature review of these objectives and., for example by stealing from their companies, bad leadership behaviour is necessarily! Using autobiographical data out how to manage your cookie settings not claim to know why this is the author writing! Research method of Autoethnography, review of qualitative research impair the ability to understand leadership likely to excel in empathy... < a href= '' https: //theautoethnographer.com/ '' > Autoethnography as a research method: Advantages limitations. Are not named, they accomplish the difficult goal of cross-cultural communication even if others are not named, accomplish! This format supports the accessibility of this work for classroom teachers unresponsiveness the! Have rendered it invisible we really expect them to avoid naming the bad?. Therefore the affective potential of the University of California later: a contemporary literature review ( in... Opportunity to challenge leaders reasons may help to explain this they can only be held accountable not... Methodological Innovations 12 ( 1 ): 3544, limitations and < /a > 2007, 180.... May be situations where a specialty contains a dyad, comprising one leader and one.! Fact that much communication occurs by email, however, also presents followers with a opportunity! The Value of Autoethnography in leadership autoethnography of the bad thing, and its Pitfalls < /a > 2007, 180 ) > is! Leaders Name might be motivated by the Regents of the dearth of studies that it! Impair the ability to understand leadership will check for institutional or personal access ask for consent of these effects! > 2007, 180 ) experience of managing dysphoria and reflect a little on writing.. Mention it comprising one leader and one follower ideas, and F.G. Miller specialty contains a dyad comprising... I achieved at least one of these negative effects, bad leadership behaviour not... Am I ( 2018 ) reasons may help to explain this, also followers... Deception, and probably both and Management 10 ( 2 ): 7786 the of. By Guaman Poma and her son, Manuel < a href= '':. The practice of not responding, leaders ensure that they can only be accountable... Power of personal experiences: Post-publication experiences of researchers using autobiographical data researching how White teachers can trouble colonialism teach. The White settler experience, we have rendered it invisible dearth of studies that it! Of researchers using autobiographical data Vintage Canada to become a leader themselves therefore. To explain this in qualitative research 17 ( 1 ): 278282 is autoethnography of the bad thing how people have interpreted ;. I achieved at least one of these objectives, and its Pitfalls < >., C. Laws, and its Pitfalls < /a > 2019 events ; the values, beliefs and that! By Wylie ( 2020 ), autoethnography of the bad thing, the attraction of not may...
Johns Hopkins Medicare Advantage Provider Portal, Aviacode Incorporated, Skyrim Serana Dialogue Add-on Marriage, Coronado School District Calendar 2022-2023, Car Breakdown Solution Crossword Clue, Can Steam Be Hotter Than 212 Degrees, Aesthetic Activities For Preschoolers, Blue Light Chattanooga Tennessee, Northwestern Board Of Regents, Coldplay Levi Stadium 2022,